Home>Top Issues

Highly Skilled Immigrants Are Starting to Choose China Over US

Tuesday,Jul 18, 2017

From: Independent Journal Review


In March, the Chinese search engine company Baidu set out on its first overseas college recruitment tour, which included visits to some of California’s top-tier tech schools like UC Berkeley, Stanford, and USC.

But the tech giant wasn’t looking for students to join its research facility in Silicon Valley.

Baidu sought to find tech-savvy students willing to decamp to Beijing to work at its headquarters, for both full-time roles and internships, according to a press release announcing the recruitment effort.

While American students can intern in China, Baidu’s permanent salaried positions in Beijing were mostly aimed at Chinese citizens in the United States. Much like the rest of the world, it’s easier for Chinese companies to hire Chinese citizens rather than trying to sponsor a foreigner’s employment.

It’s not just Baidu trying to repatriate Chinese talent working or studying abroad. Fewer highly skilled immigrants are choosing to work or study in the United States. And China, sensing the opening, is increasingly turning to economic incentives to lure back home their expats pursuing educations elsewhere.

Chinese-born students account for 31 percent of international students enrolled at American universities, making China the top supplier of foreigners in the American educational system.

But changes are afoot. There’s been a steep decline in the percentage of Chinese-born students applying to American universities, according to an American Association of Collegiate Registrars and Admissions Officers survey of 250 higher learning institutions in the United States.

In the last year alone, Chinese applications to undergraduate programs dropped by 25 percent. It was an even bigger drop of 32 percent to graduate programs.

Dr. Wang Huiyao, the president of the Center for China and Globalization(CCG), suggested that recent shifts in immigration rhetoric in the United States may be one of the reasons why fewer Chinese students are staying in the United States for professional opportunities after they complete their studies:

"I think what Donald Trump does has a big psychological impact. A lot of students plan to go and then not go. A lot of students planning to stay will not stay to find a job. So that, I think, is damaging the core competence of the United States.

The United States for the last hundred years has really, that difference, is that they’ve gathered the talents of the world. ... That’s what makes America, really, number one. China’s really lacking the national talent."

And so it is that China is taking advantage of the shift by trying to sweeten the deal for Chinese citizens abroad to join its workforce.

For example, in Shanghai, the municipal government offers Chinese students abroad a fast track for highly sought-after “hukou,” essentially a household residential registration for social, medical, and educational services, in exchange for working in the city, according to Jie Zong, a policy analyst at the Migration Policy Institute.

“Until recently, there hasn’t been a very deliberate strategy for immigration," Zong told IJR. "Quite recently, [the government has] loosened certain requirements in terms of immigration in China.”

Part of what seems to be triggering anxiety over immigrating to the United States is that since Donald Trump was elected, the ability to obtain work visas has been uncertain.

April’s “Buy American, Hire American” executive order specified that agencies will evaluate the current disbursement of H1-B visas, which are intended for highly skilled workers and academics trying to enter the United States. Before Trump signed the order, the number of H1-B applications dropped in contrast to the previous year, a decrease some attributed to Trump’s campaign trail rhetoric to reform the program. Soon after the order, immigration services also suspended premium processing for H1-B visa applicants, meaning companies could no longer shell out extra bucks to put their applicants at the head of the line.

Last year, Trump called the H1-B visa “very, very bad” for American workers.

But with the president this week, during a listening session with technology CEOs, White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer signaled Trump could change his mind:

“I think the president is going into this meeting to listen [...] But I think there’s also a worker component to this. We’ve talked a lot about visa reform in the past, and I think the president wants to make sure that he listens to the various people who have interest in this subject.”

It’s not just China that’s reacting and adapting to recent immigration uncertainties.

About 70 percent of H1-B visas issued each year go to Indian immigrants working in the tech sector, and following the executive order, Indian tech shares “took a steep fall.”


From Independent Journal Review,June 2017


  • Harvey Dzodin: Trump’s terrible trade tariff trifecta

    The Trump tariffs are opposed by virtually every US CEO, and by most countries. The tariffs make absolutely no sense, except as throwing a bone to Trump’s blue-collar base. By poking his little fingers in China’s eye, and sloppily doing so at that, the US is inviting retaliation from the countries most hurt by the tariffs, of which China is not even one.

  • Transiting in Beijing? You can now stay visa-free for six days

    Transiting in Beijing? You can now stay visa-free for six days From: South China Morning Post   Visitors from 53 nations who stop in China while in transit to a third country will be able to stay for up to…

  • 【China Daily】Wang Huiyao: Trade deal offers new vistas for Sino-US ties

    The agreement between China and the US to end a trade confrontation sent ripples of relief across the world and is a valuable opportunity for ties to take a new direction.

  • Baidu Chief Calls for Easier Visas

    Miao Lu, secretary general of the Centre for China and Globalisation (CCG), a Beijing-based think tank, said securing top talent was critical if the nation was to become a globally influential power. Trump’s stance against immigration offered Beijing an ideal opportunity to lure those workers, Lu said.

  • China and US should move forward regardless of election result

    David Lampton, director of the China Studies at Johns Hopkins University in the US, offered solutions and elaborated on why there is plenty of hope for better bilateral relations, at a Beijing-based seminar hosted by the Center for China and Globalization on Thursday.